Mr. Beer Craft Beer Making Kit Review

Most homebrewers' first beer comes from a Mr. Beer kit. The 4-gallon Craft Beer Making Kit ($56, 4.3 stars, 750+ reviews) bundles fermenter, recipe ingredients, bottles, and instructions in one box. We tested it over 4 batches against the traditional 5-gallon-bucket path.

TL;DR

The right starter kit for testing whether homebrewing is for you. 4-gallon plastic fermenter (smaller than industry-standard 5-gallon), pre-portioned ingredient kits (extract-based), 11 PET plastic bottles, no-boil simplified process. First batch ready in 2-3 weeks. Skip if you're already serious about the craft (start with Northern Brewer 5-gallon kit and full equipment); pick this for risk-free testing.

Why It Matters

Homebrewing has a steep starter cost: ~$150-200 for full 5-gallon equipment, ingredient costs separate, and a multi-hour process for the first batch. Mr. Beer compresses all this into one $56 box with a simplified no-boil process — you mix the included extract with water, pitch yeast, ferment 2 weeks, bottle.

The simplification is a tradeoff. You don't learn full process (no boil = no hop bittering control); you can't easily scale recipes; ingredients beyond included refills are limited. But for a first batch that proves whether you enjoy the hobby, Mr. Beer works.

Key Specs

• Fermenter capacity: 4 gallon (vs industry 5 gallon)
• Material: Food-grade plastic
• Process: No-boil; mix extract + water + yeast
• Includes: Fermenter, recipe pack (ingredients for 1 batch), 11 PET bottles, sanitizer, instructions
• Bottle size: ~16 oz PET plastic
• Time to first beer: 2-3 weeks total
• Refill kits: Sold separately ($15-25)
• Country of origin: USA (Coopers/Mr. Beer)

Pros

• All-in-one $56. Lowest barrier to first batch.
• No-boil simplified process. Mix and ferment; minimal time investment.
• Pre-portioned ingredients. No measuring or recipe formulation.
• Light fermenter. Easy to lift; fits on counter.
• Recipe variety. Refill kits available in various beer styles.
• Risk-free testing. Buy in store; brew within hour of unboxing.
• Compact storage. 4-gallon fermenter is shelf-sized.

Cons

• No boil = limited hop control. Can't replicate hop-forward styles authentically.
• PET plastic bottles less durable than glass. Replace yearly.
• 4-gallon is non-standard. Future recipe scaling needs conversion.
• Refill kits limit to Mr. Beer recipes. Hard to expand beyond.
• Fermenter scratches over time. Replace after ~10 batches.
• No advanced control. Temperature, sparge, mash skipped.

Who It's For

• Homebrew curious. Wanting to test before investing in 5-gallon kit.
• Apartment dwellers. Compact 4-gallon fits small spaces.
• Gift recipients. Common starter gift; low-friction unboxing.
• Single-batch tasters. Brewing one style and stopping.
• Beer-style explorers. Wanting to taste-test before brewing 5-gallon batches.
• Skip if you're already committed to homebrewing (jump to Northern Brewer 5-gallon), if you want to brew hop-forward styles authentically (need full boil), or if you want to scale recipes from Mr. Beer to industry-standard.

How to Use

• Sanitize fermenter and bottles with included sanitizer
• Heat included extract in water per instructions
• Add to fermenter; top off with cold water to fill line
• Pitch dry yeast (included)
• Ferment 2 weeks at room temperature
• Bottle into PET bottles with priming sugar (included)
• Carbonate 1-2 weeks at room temperature
• Refrigerate; drink

How It Compares

• vs Northern Brewer 1 Gallon Kit ($110): Northern Brewer 1-gal teaches more of full process. Comparable starter tier; pick by interest level.
• vs Northern Brewer 5 Gallon Starter Kit ($156): 5-gal is industry-standard; teaches full process. Pick for serious commitment.
• vs Brooklyn Brew Shop 1 Gallon Kit ($65): BBS uses all-grain mini-mashing. More authentic process at small scale.
• vs Bare 5-Gallon Bucket + Refill ($40): Cheapest path but no recipes or instructions; harder learning curve.

Bottom Line

Mr. Beer Craft Beer Making Kit is the right risk-free starter for homebrew-curious users. All-in-one $56, no-boil simplified process, fast time to first beer. Northern Brewer 5-gallon is the upgrade for serious commitment; Brooklyn Brew Shop is the more-authentic small-batch alternative. For "the kit that proves whether homebrewing is for you," this earns the slot.

Check the latest price on Amazon.